Tuesday, June 17, 2008

We are All Proud to Say We're Nurses---Aren't We?

I don’t know how to begin this; I don’t have a smooth segue into a story that lacks an earthshaking quality because it deals with a common emotion—embarrassment. But, it is somewhat intriguing—at least to me. I have a strong interest in people, their personalities, their jobs, what they do for fun and what motivates them to do what they do. The questions just pour out of me, to the point of bordering on interrogation. My friend says I’m curious, my husband says I’m nosy and my sister is puzzled as to why I would even want to know these things.

At my nursing school, our very first patient assignment was to simply chat at the bedside of a patient and learn as much as we could about that patient. We students and our instructor then congregated to share the information we’d gleaned from the patients. To restate the popular "boys with the most toys" phrase, "the nurse who asks the most questions wins." I always won. Things just kind of snowballed from there.

At an event at a Boulder, Colorado mountaineering shop last week, I ran into a friend who introduced me to a premier climber who writes magazine articles and books on climbing. So, the questions began (my friends call it playing The Glenna Game) and soon I learned that his fiancée is a RN. He introduced us via e-mail the next day and, yes, The Glenna Game ensued.

I learned she is a woman of the great outdoors, a climber and a wilderness EMT who has taught W-EMT to climbers, hikers and rafters. She is an ED nurse at a prestigious hospital for children and she told me she loves her job—really loves her job.

I learned through our e-mail conversations that she is currently mentoring a new nurse, a 29-year-old male who is also a climber. She asked why he hadn’t gone to nursing school as a traditional-aged college student and he admitted that it was because he was embarrassed to have to say he was studying nursing. He was working in the outdoor industry, and also as a wilderness EMT, teaching life-saving skills to backcountry warriors, mostly male. The stereotypical nurse image conflicted with his established macho image.

I don’t know how he managed to overcome his image issues and move forward with a nursing career but I’m glad he got past it—if he did. I say that because my new e-friend then dropped the bomb that she, too, has felt embarrassment when telling certain people, primarily the rugged climbing crowd she hangs with, that she is a nurse, particularly a neonatal ICU nurse, which she was in her first job.

She’d wanted to be a veterinarian but in her freshman year of college someone told her there was a glut of vets, jobs were scarce and if she wanted to have a job after college she’d be wiser to go to nursing school—so she did. She didn’t come with the built-in nurse gene. She didn’t want to be a traditional nurse and, to this day, the angel of mercy perception of nurses still chafes. Her nursing school graduating class even voted her "Most Likely to Change Careers." But, she has been at it for 13 years.

My impression is that her 13 years as a nurse have resolved her image issues but, as a
new graduate and for a few years beyond, she struggled when in the presence of certain company. AJN editor, Diana Mason, RN, PhD, FAAN was right when she said, "It does take something special to be a good nurse but it doesn’t have to be innate. With the proper desire, skills can be learned." Having pride in one’s profession also can be learned.

I’ve always been proud to be a nurse and feel that every nurse should be, but I won’t pass judgement on these two nurses. We all come with full sets of jam-packed baggage that shape our self-perceptions and how we want others to perceive us. Lots of factors are at work here, among them our country’s stereotypes of nurses, male and female. I think it just takes time to sort through our baggage in order to find our way to the place we need to be, to discover the person we are supposed to be and to become comfortable with that place and that person.

I also think every nurse has unique talents. Nurses aren’t made using the same cookie cutter, nor should they be. My e-friend’s favorite nursing experience was four months spent as a volunteer, assisting with surgeries in rural areas of Nepal. Not every nurse would or could do that, but it is wonderful that she did. I’ll even admit that I’m grateful that she, in effect, went in my place.

If you have had trouble coming to terms with being a nurse, I’d like to hear your story. Let’s hear your comments.

3 comments:

phaedra said...

I find your post very interesting. I have often pondered this myself. I know for me, I am very proud to be a nurse. Not only do I view nursing as my job, I consider it my calling and ministry. It warms my heart to be able to extend my hands and help someone. I love the role. It completes my natural longing to be a nurturer and caregiver. It upsets me when someone says " oh, well. It's just a job". To me, it is more than that. I have worked hard and continue to work hard to be the best I can be and am very proud to say I am a NURSE.

Phaedra Alwell
LVN

Anonymous said...

I have a been a RN for 25 years, all of the time in hospital nursing. In that time I have never gone anywhere in public in my scrubs. If I meeting for dinner, a meeting, etc. I will bring a change of clothes. I very seldom tell people what I do. I don't think embarrassment or shame is the appopriate term. It's more I'm am so tired of hearing the comments saying how they pity the profession, or they half-hearted admiration, or "My --- is a nurse". The years of seeing the nursing practice and standards becoming meaningless in the corporate eye has led to great apathy for patient care. The passive aggressive behavior that is bred and sustained in the hospital setting leads to very interesting behaviors. I, the person who admittedly does not care, am the most experienced on the floor, precepts most of the new nurses, and undoubtedly the unit resource person. The irony is blatantly obvious. I work only weekends, so that I have four days to do what I like to do and get more satisfaction from.

Glenna Murdock, RN said...

Yours is an interesting take on changes in the profession and patient care. It sounds like you might be emotionally worn out. I know because I've been there. For me, it was a case of just being tired of beating my head against a wall, unable to accomplish all I wanted because of the road blocks that were put in my way. It was such a feeling of defeat. I got lucky--my husband was transfered to another state and the move gave me a much needed change. Got a job I loved!

Good luck,
glenna