Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Nurse Dramas---Helping or Hurting?

I’m surprised by my interest in and excitement about the new nurse-centered TV dramas, Nurse Jackie and HawthoRNe (and Mercy projected to debut in the fall lineup). I suppose that some of my reaction is in response to the efforts of Sandy Summers who, as the former voice of The Center for Nursing Advocacy and presently that of The Truth About Nursing, has kept a close eye on TV medical dramas and diligently campaigned for the accurate portrayal of nurses and nursing.

Summers communicates frequently with writers and producers, calling them to task for relegating nurses to insignificant roles while showing physicians performing the lifesaving skills that nurses do every day. She was told, time and again, that the viewing public is simply not interested in stories about nurses, only physicians.

From reading the accounts of her interactions with TV brass, it certainly appeared that Hollywood had its heels dug in and no changes were forthcoming. I am very curious to know if it was Summers’s persistent urging, or something else, that motivated producers to give nurses a chance to star on the small screen in not one, but three, shows—a remarkable about face.

Writers have given Jackie and Hawthorne powerful roles but also personal foibles, namely Jackie’s prescription drug addiction and Hawthorne’s rebellious daughter, in addition to questionable behavior on the parts of both nurses.

It’s early in the game but the shows are stirring up controversy within the nursing profession. The Center for Nursing Advocacy wants to explore this controversy and is asking nurses to respond to the Center’s discussion board to voice their opinions.

Go to the Center’s Web site, click on ‘discussion board’ and tell the Center what you think regarding these two questions:

1. Do you think Nurse Jackie and HawthoRNe are helping or hurting nursing?
2. How can nurses, including nursing faculty, use Nurse Jackie and HawthoRNe to educate their peers and students about the importance of becoming advocates for the nursing profession?

I’d also like to hear your opinions. Please share them here.


Anonymous said...

While channel surfing late one night, I came upon Nurse Jackie. It was during a commercial break. I was excited to indulge in some tv commrodarie (spelling?). Well, a few minutes is all I needed to completely repulse me. Of course, as nurses, we are human with our own shortcomings and individual circumstances. But this was just too much. The drug abuse, adultery, family deception and talking like a truck driver (no offense intended, just an expression), all within a matter of 5-7 minutes was so unrepresentative of the wonderful colleages I have had the privilege to work with, and the lives we have touched. I won't waste my precious down time on such trash again.

Anonymous said...

If you like Desperate Housewives, you'll love Nurse Jackie. Just dress everyone in nurses uniforms. Need I say more?

Glenna Murdock said...

Thanks to both of you for your comments. I have cable but not HBO so the only episode of Jackie that I've seen was the first episode, shown as a freebie online prior to the series debut. It was, without a doubt, sensational but debut shows often are in order to hook an audience and then they level out somewhat. Without HBO there's no way I can check up on that. I understand that some of the goings on would be distasteful but I ask these two responders if you in any way feel that Jackie's take charge image (nurse as highly trained practitioner) can offset the negative behaviors. I'm just curious.


james said...

Earn a Degree Online

Earning your degree online has never been easier. It is now possible to go to school, work, and your other obligations and still maintain an up to date education by taking your courses online. With the recent technological advancements, some online schools have now found new way for students and teachers to interact with each other through different mediums online. Webcams, instant messengers, e-mail, messages boards and VIOP systems have now all been implemented into online courses all across the world, making it much easier for students to ask questions and still have that face to face feel of a tradition college or university……….

students zone

Curlygirl said...

I am a HawthoRNe fan hands down!!!

MattBuckland857 said...

Takabbur In a recent interview, Kajol talked about her craze for Pakistani dramas. She said a while back it would have been totally impossible for a Bollywood actor to religiously follow Pakistani soaps or be enthusiastic about them, but things have totally changed.